Pros 
Cons )
A Slice of Heaven: The Lucky Pig's Stellar Reputation
The Lucky Pig, nestled at 452 Centre Rd, Bentleigh VIC 3204, has firmly established itself as a beloved cornerstone of the local community and a serious contender for Melbourne's best butcher shop. Boasting a remarkable rating of 4.8 out of 5, it's clear this isn’t just a place to buy meat; it’s an experience. Numerous reviews highlight the consistently high quality of their meat, frequently mentioning the succulent lamb, gorgeous veal fillets, and perfectly prepared souvlaki meat. Customers consistently praise the shop's ability to cater to specific requests – a departure from many other butchers where custom orders are a hassle. Indeed, the shop excels at accommodating unique needs, whether it's a Thanksgiving turkey and ham combo or complex smoking/BBQ cuts.
Beyond the quality of the product, The Lucky Pig shines brightly when it comes to service. The team, led by Luke, is consistently described as friendly, helpful, and accommodating. One reviewer recounts a delightful experience where the staff went above and beyond, offering to crumb veal fillets while they waited – a gesture completely free of charge. Luke's responsiveness and organizational skills extend beyond individual customers, with a property manager highlighting his reliability as a supplier, particularly valuable during busy festive seasons. The willingness to understand and execute customer requests, even unconventional ones like a hefty order of marinated souvlaki meat, consistently earns praise. And let's not forget the recent generosity; The Lucky Pig’s donation towards a Beyond Blue fundraiser was met with sincere gratitude – a testament to the shop's community spirit.
Menu Highlights & Special Touches
The Lucky Pig doesn't just sell meat; it sells culinary inspiration. While their standard cuts are consistently praised, several dishes and services clearly stand out:
- Souvlaki Meat: The marinated lamb and chicken are massively popular, consistently earning rave reviews for their succulent flavour and promotion of memorable parties.
- Veal Fillets: The gorgeous looking quality of the veal fillets is regularly mentioned, and the offer to crumb them on the spot is a significant draw.
- Smoking/BBQ Cuts: A rare find in Melbourne, The Lucky Pig genuinely understands and caters to the BBQ enthusiast, with a wide range of specialist cuts always in stock.
- Thanksgiving Specialties: Serving as a testament to their accommodating nature, their turkey and ham services are a hit for festive celebrations.
- Free Meatball Subs: A delightful surprise and a taste of what to expect at the Bentleigh Festival!
Beyond individual items, the shop’s ability to create custom orders is a huge differentiator. Need a particular cut prepared a specific way? The Lucky Pig's team are generally happy to oblige, either immediately or with a day's notice for more complex requirements. Their understanding of different cooking styles and preferences makes them a true partner in meal preparation.
Accessibility, Services & Payment Options
The Lucky Pig clearly focuses on providing a convenient and accessible experience for all customers:
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Accessibility | Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking. |
| Service Options | Delivery, In-store pickup, and Onsite services. Sadly, same-day delivery isn't currently offered. |
| Planning | Ideal for a quick visit, making it easy to pop in and grab what you need. |
| Payment Methods | Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments. |
| Opening Hours | Monday - Friday: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM, Saturday: 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM, Sunday: Closed |
| Contact | +61 3 9557 5611 |
These features contribute to a welcoming environment and streamlined shopping experience. The accessible facilities, combined with the option for delivery and in-store pickup, demonstrate a commitment to catering to diverse needs.
A Word of Caution & Addressing Concerns
While overwhelmingly positive, a few reviews flag areas for improvement, particularly concerning pricing transparency. One customer expressed disappointment with an incident involving lamb fat and lamb mince, feeling the pricing was opportunistic. Although the issue was ultimately resolved with a refund, the initial feeling of being treated unfairly remains a concern. It's worth noting this was an isolated incident, and the reviewer acknowledged the shop's generally high quality.
It is important for The Lucky Pig to be mindful of potential perceptions of price gouging, particularly when dealing with less common requests. Maintaining open communication about pricing and ensuring clarity in transactions can prevent misunderstandings and reinforce the shop's reputation for honesty and integrity. While Luke encourages return customers, the incident highlights the importance of earned trust, and consistency in treating all customers fairly.
Despite this singular point of contention, the enduring praise for The Lucky Pig’s quality, service, and prices solidifies its place as a top butcher shop in Bentleigh and a favourite amongst Melbourne locals.