Michael's Finest Meats: Quality Cuts and Customer Controversies

's response

A Mixed Grill of Experiences: What Customers Are Saying About Michael's Finest Meats

Michael's Finest Meats, nestled in Caringbah at 58 President Ave, has become a local talking point – and not always for the right reasons. The butcher shop, boasting a 3.7-star rating, clearly offers high-quality meat, earning praise for everything from tender chops to catering capabilities. However, a concerning thread of complaints regarding pricing discrepancies and hygiene practices has emerged within customer reviews. Let's unpack the sentiment surrounding this Caringbah institution and delve into what customers love and what leaves them feeling short-changed. The shop's opening hours are convenient, operating from 6 AM to 6 PM most days, and 6 AM to 5 PM on Sundays. They offer wheelchair accessible entrance and parking, catering to customers with mobility needs, and are equipped for quick visits. Accepted payment methods include debit and credit cards, and NFC mobile payment.

The Highs: Quality, Freshness and Handy Service

Despite the controversies, a significant number of reviewers highlight the exceptional quality of the meat sold at Michael's Finest Meats. The recurring praise focuses on:

• Superior Quality: Several customers consistently describe the meat as "fabulous" and "great quality," using descriptors such as "tender" and "tasty." Many specifically mention the chicken thighs being "always trimmed and fresh"—a small detail that contributes significantly to overall satisfaction.
• Catering Capabilities: One customer was particularly impressed with the shop’s ability to assist with a last-minute catering order for 70 people, describing the “service and quality” as “amazing.” This points to a willingness to go above and beyond for larger orders.
• Friendly Staff (Sometimes): While not universally reported, many customers mention friendly staff. One review specifically calls out an employee named Hugh, although in a negative context, indicating Michael's employs a range of personalities.
• Variety: The butcher shop is often commended for the variety of products offered, suggesting a comprehensive selection to meet diverse customer needs.

The Lows: Pricing Concerns and Hygiene Concerns

Unfortunately, the positive reviews are often contrasted with serious concerns regarding pricing and hygiene standards. These are the most frequently cited drawbacks:

• Frequent Overcharging: A recurring theme in the reviews is being incorrectly charged for more expensive cuts of meat. Customers report consistently paying more than expected, sometimes by a significant margin (one account mentions a 15% overpayment). This is compounded by the fact that register prices don't always match the prices displayed on signs.
• Lack of Transparency & Rude Service: The issue isn’t merely the overcharging itself, but the lack of accountability. Customers describe being met with resistance when pointing out errors and a distinct lack of apologies when mistakes are made. A particularly concerning incident highlights a receipt that fails to comply with ACCC requirements, displaying no product details or pricing information, making it impossible to verify charges. This effectively leaves customers to rely on their mental arithmetic.
• Hygiene Practices – A Major Red Flag: Several reviewers have expressed significant alarm about hygiene practices. Specifically, multiple accounts describe staff handling cash, EFTPOS machines, and then using the same bare hands to select and package meat for customers. This poses a serious health risk and has led at least one customer to vow never to return.

  “The staff using their bare hands to grab meat for customers, the same bare hands they are using to handle cash, eftpos machines and god only knows what else. Yuk, I won't be going back here. Come on people, be smart and hygienic!"

A Call for Change: What’s Next for Michael’s Finest Meats?

The current feedback paints a complex picture of Michael's Finest Meats. The butcher shop undoubtedly offers excellent quality meat and occasionally impressive service for larger orders. However, the consistent complaints regarding pricing, receipt transparency and, most disturbingly, hygiene practices, are serious issues that require immediate attention.

Here's what needs to happen to address customer concerns:

• Implement a Clear Pricing System: Align register prices with signage and train staff to accurately ring up purchases.
• Correct Receipt Practices: Adhere to ACCC requirements, providing detailed receipts that clearly list products purchased and their corresponding prices.
• Mandatory Hygiene Training: Implement strict hygiene protocols, including the mandatory use of gloves when handling meat and separating food preparation areas from cash handling.
• Customer Service Improvement: Equip staff to handle pricing disputes professionally and with genuine apologies when errors occur. A more proactive approach to customer satisfaction could significantly improve Michael’s reputation.

Phone: +61 2 9524 7405 Address: 58 President Ave, Caringbah NSW 2229, Australia