Pros 
Cons Mixed Reviews: A Tasting Tour at Vic's Chadstone
Vic's Chadstone stands as a unique establishment combining a butcher shop and deli, located at 1341 Dandenong Rd in Malvern East, VIC. With an average rating of 3.2 stars, the feedback showcases a tapestry of opinions that range from praise to significant complaints. Below, we dive into what customers are saying about this local haunt.
Highlights and Praises
Delicious Reuben Sandwich
Many diners rave about the Reuben sandwich, with one reviewer aptly stating, “Best Reuben I’ve had, and I’ve had a lot of them!” Customers have noted the sandwich's perfect meat temperature and ideal sauerkraut-to-meat ratio.Croquettes and Loaded Fries
The chicken, pastrami, and jalapeno croquettes have received high marks for their flavor. One happy patron mentioned:“Loaded fries and Vic’s Deli roll were all delicious and I would gladly spend my money trying out each menu item.”
Charming Atmosphere
The decor at Vic's exudes an old-school diner vibe that appeals to many. The combination of a dry-aging room and a well-stocked deli also heightens the excitement of the shopping experience.
Areas for Improvement
Limited Seating
Several customers have pointed out the constrained seating arrangements, potentially making it challenging for larger groups to dine in together, especially during peak hours.Quality vs. Price Discrepancy
Some diners criticize the price-to-quality ratio, particularly for sandwiches. One reviewer expressed disappointment after ordering a Reuben that they described as the “saltiest and driest sandwich” they had ever encountered, which left them feeling it did not justify the $24 price tag.Dry Meat
Another recurring theme is the dryness of certain sandwiches, particularly the Chevapi. As a disappointed customer noted, the dish was overpriced, yet lacked the savoury delight expected from such a premium option.
Customer Insights
Diverse Opinions on Meats
Reviewers' attitudes toward Vic's butcher services vary. While some hail it as a premium vendor, others argue that the prices for beef and poultry appear excessive and uncompetitive.Sandwich Not to Write Home About
Many customers express that while the sandwiches are tasty, they feel the size and quantity don’t measure up to the steep prices. One customer’s experience summarized it neatly: “Tasty but average servings for New York deli prices.”
| Item | Praise | Complaints |
|---|---|---|
| Reuben Sandwich | Great flavour, perfect temperature | Some say it's small and overpriced |
| Croquettes | Delicious and full of flavour | N/A |
| Chips | Often described as overly salty | Too much salt |
Final Thoughts: A Place of Contrasts
Vic's Chadstone showcases a fusion of culinary delights and frustrations. The praise for its Reuben and fantastic croquettes is often rivalled by criticisms of dryness, price, and regrettably salted chips. While some find themselves cheering for Vic's unabashed commitment to quality, others feel the establishment is trying to stretch its wings without a sturdy foundation underneath.
Whether you're looking for top-tier meats or a gourmet sandwich experience, a visit to Vic's Chadstone may warrant either excitement or disappointment—all depending on what you’re seeking. With its eclectic mix of offerings, this butcher shop deli continues to invite mixed reviews from its patrons.