Pros 
Cons Silvestro Butchers: Why Locals Drive Past Seven Other Butchers
Silvestro Butchers, nestled at 7/227 Main St, Osborne Park, has garnered a remarkable 4.8-star rating, and the devotion of its customers is palpable. It’s not just that they’re a good butcher; many patrons—and we're talking people who have seven butchers closer to home—are willing to travel past those alternatives specifically to shop at Silvestro. This level of dedication speaks volumes about the quality and experience provided within its walls. Forget convenience; for these customers, it’s a pilgrimage for premium meat. Phone: +61 8 6478 0894. Opening Hours are consistent, running Monday to Friday from 8 AM to 5 PM, and Saturday until 2 PM. Sunday is a well-deserved day of rest.
Here’s a deeper look into what makes Silvestro Butchers so special – and a couple of considerations to be aware of.
A Product Paradise: The overwhelming sentiment amongst reviews is one of superlative quality. Customers repeatedly use phrases like "best I've ever eaten" to describe Silvestro's offerings. Here’s a breakdown of some frequently praised products:
- Sausages: Consistently highlighted as exceptional.
- Cutlets: Another fan favourite.
- Meatballs: Apparently, they're a must-try.
- Kievs: Often mentioned in the same breath as "best ever."
- Brisket: Described as "amazing" and perfectly executed. One reviewer even noted it was "nailed."
- Pork Belly: A standout dish according to several reviews.
- Ribeye Steaks: Particularly the thick-cut variety, are highly recommended for a juicy and flavourful experience.
- Eye Fillet: A reliable favourite for new and long-term customers alike.
- Shanghai Pork: Specifically called out as an excellent BBQ choice.
Accessibility & Convenience Combined
Feature Details Service Options In-store pickup and onsite services are readily available. Accessibility Wheelchair accessible entrance and dedicated parking. Planning Ideal for quick visits – get in and out efficiently. Payment Options Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments.
The Upsides: Quality, Service, and a Welcoming Atmosphere
Beyond the beautiful cuts of meat, Silvestro Butchers stands out for its exceptional service. Multiple reviews emphasize the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff. The overall impression is one of a welcoming, knowledgeable team dedicated to providing a positive customer experience. Here's a detailed look at what customers rave about:
- Unwavering Friendliness: "The most friendliest and helpful staff in the business." This recurring theme reinforces a feeling of personalized attention and genuine care.
- Consistent Quality (for most products): Customers who have been regulars for years consistently report never having a bad experience with the products – a testament to the butcher’s commitment to quality and consistency.
- Freshness: Newcomers to the area have also been impressed by the freshness of all products, noting the availability of eye fillet every visit.
- Beautiful Presentation: One review specifically noted that the produce is "beautifully presented," suggesting attention to detail extends beyond just quality—it's an aesthetically pleasing experience, too.
- Reasonable Pricing: While the quality is outstanding, one customer remarked about pricing being "so reasonable" that it's barely noticeable – a strong indicator of great value.
A Minor Caveat: The Mince Experience
While overwhelmingly positive, a significant number of reviews for Silvestro Butchers highlight a perceived issue with their mince. One customer, while otherwise impressed, encountered a disappointing experience with the burger mince.
“Paid top dollar for some disgusting tasting mince, unsure if it’s due to the fat to mince ratio, but if you’re after burger mince goto troys meat in same area. Made burgers the same way I would normally taste and smell un eatable.”
This suggests a potential issue with the fat-to-mince ratio, resulting in an unpalatable flavour. Another reviewer suggested trying Troy's Meat, located nearby, for a better burger mince alternative. While this is a single point of concern amidst numerous positive reviews, it’s worth noting for potential customers, particularly those specifically seeking burger mince. Silvestro Butchers’ payments system includes options for credit, debit, and NFC mobile payment options.
Final Thoughts: Is Silvestro Butchers Worth the Trip?
The evidence strongly suggests that for most, the answer is a resounding yes. The willingness of customers to drive past closer, more convenient butchers is a compelling endorsement of Silvestro Butchers' commitment to quality, service, and a welcoming atmosphere. While the mince issue warrants consideration for certain purchases, the vast majority of offerings – from sausages to steaks – are consistently lauded as exceptional. The accessible location, convenient opening hours (7 AM - 5 PM Monday-Friday, 7 AM - 2 PM Saturday), and range of payment options further enhance the overall experience. If you’re in the Osborne Park area, or willing to make a worthwhile detour, Silvestro Butchers is absolutely worth a visit.