Pros 
Cons Exceptional Quality and Freshness
Peter Da Silva Poultry & Selected Meats has earned a reputation for providing exceptional quality meats—particularly their Halal offerings. Customers rave about the freshness of the products available at this Elsternwick butcher shop. With a rating of 4.3 out of 5, it’s evident that many locals have appreciated their experience here.
- Halal Options: The shop has become a go-to spot for those seeking authentic Halal meat. Customers have expressed satisfaction with the high quality and variety of meats available.
- Poultry Selection: Whether it's chicken necks for pets or premium-quality chicken cuts, their selection impresses both home cooks and pet owners alike.
As one loyal patron puts it, “If you value fresh, premium-quality Halal products served with a smile, this is the perfect spot.”
Outstanding Customer Service
Uncle, the beloved shopkeeper, is pivotal to the warm atmosphere that patrons enjoy at Peter Da Silva Poultry & Selected Meats. His friendly and respectful demeanor adds a welcoming touch:
- Personal Connection: Customers feel valued, often referring to Uncle as part of the family. His dedication to hygiene and maintaining the authenticity of products is commendable.
- Knowledgeable Staff: Beyond just Uncle, the team is reported to be helpful and knowledgeable, guiding customers through various product choices with a smile.
A recent visitor shared, “The gentleman who served me was splendid too, helped me out efficiently with a smile on his face.”
Varied Meat Selections
The diverse meat selections at this butcher shop ensure that there’s something for everyone—be it a family gathering, a barbecue, or an everyday meal.
- Gourmet Options: From ready-to-cook schnitzels to gourmet poultry sausages, the variety caters to different culinary needs and preferences.
- Competitive Pricing: Many customers have noted the reasonable prices for high-quality meats, although there are a few who feel certain cuts might be overpriced.
As one customer remarked, “On top of the standard cuts, a great selection of gourmet poultry sausages accompany surprising prices.”
| Product | Price |
|---|---|
| Marinated Porterhouse | $35/kg |
| Unmarinated Porterhouse | $47/kg |
Customers have shared both enthusiasm and caution regarding pricing, showcasing a mixed experience between quality and value.
Room for Improvement
Despite the many positive reviews, some feedback does reflect concerns that Peter Da Silva Poultry & Selected Meats may want to address:
- Quality Control Issues: There have been instances where customers reported receiving spoiled meat, impacting their overall experience. One dissatisfied customer voiced, “Ordered 1.2kg of beef ribs on Uber Eats. Meat came and smelled awful.”
- Pricing Discrepancies: Some shoppers feel that certain cuts are priced too high for what is offered, leading to mixed feelings about value.
In the words of a recent visitor, “Marinated porterhouse is $35/kg. I asked them to cut me some unmarinated porterhouse. No problem. $47/kg!!!! Is it wagyu? No. What a ripoff.”
While these negative experiences represent a minority, they highlight areas where the team could focus on improving customer satisfaction, especially regarding product freshness and pricing.
Overall, Peter Da Silva Poultry & Selected Meats has established itself as a cherished local butcher, with its quality meats, welcoming service, and variety of offerings shining brightly among its competitiors—and like any establishment, there’s always room for growth and enhancement.