Pros 
Cons 's content:
A Mixed Bag of Reviews: What Customers Are Saying About Tip Top Meats
Tip Top Meats, nestled on Bolton Street in Eltham, holds a respectable 4.7-star rating on various platforms. However, a closer look at customer reviews reveals a complex picture. While many praise the shop for its friendly staff and wide selection, a recurring theme of unmet expectations regarding product availability casts a shadow on the overall experience. The shop operates with convenient hours, open Monday through Friday from 8:30 AM to 6:00 PM, Saturdays from 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM, and Sundays from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM. They cater to accessibility needs with a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot, and offer in-store pickup and shopping. Payment options include debit cards, credit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
Availability Concerns: The Elephant in the Room
The most significant criticism levelled at Tip Top Meats revolves around stock discrepancies. Several reviewers, including one long-time customer, express frustration with items listed online failing to be present in the store. This issue is highlighted in a detailed account from a customer who experienced this repeatedly across three visits:
- Duck Legs: Despite clear mention on the website, the shop reportedly lacked duck legs on the first visit.
- Beef Short Rib: The same reviewer encountered a lack of beef short rib on a subsequent visit.
- Chicken Thighs: The final disappointment came with the unavailability of chicken thighs, replaced instead with Maryland chicken – a deboned thigh and drumstick option deemed poorly trimmed and requiring further butchering by the customer.
This pattern raises serious questions. Is the website's inventory inaccurate? Are stock levels poorly managed? The customer’s observation that the shop doesn't appear to do any butchering onsite suggests a reliance on pre-packaged cuts, diminishing the value proposition of a traditional butcher shop—the ability to request specific cuts and preparation. The frustration is compounded by the fact that comparable, or even superior, products are readily available at supermarkets for similar prices. The anonymous reviewer bluntly asks, "What’s the point?" This concern clearly resonates with some customers, leading them to question the justification for a special trip.
Shining Customer Service and a Wide Variety Butchers Some Stock
Despite the frustration over availability, numerous customers highlight the exceptional service provided by Tip Top Meats’ staff. This consistently earns high praise. Examples include:
- Outstanding Customer Service: Several reviews explicitly describe the staff as "outstanding," "amazing," and "friendly," creating a "friendly environment."
- Above and Beyond for Customers: One particularly touching anecdote details how staff went above and beyond to assist a customer whose son was experiencing an overstimulation episode, bringing their order to the car. This kind of personalized service fosters loyalty and is frequently cited as a major strength of the business.
- Good Variety: A broad range of meats and frozen seafood are frequently mentioned. Many appreciate the availability of grass-fed and finished options, alongside more common selections.
- Competitive Pricing: One enthusiastic reviewer highlights the price of porterhouse ($21/kg) as a particularly positive aspect.
Here's a table summarizing the positive aspects frequently praised by customers:
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Customer Service | Exceptional, friendly, helpful, going the extra mile |
| Product Range | Wide selection of meats & seafood, including premium options |
| Pricing | Competitive, particularly for popular cuts like porterhouse |
| Atmosphere | Friendly and welcoming |
The Verdict: Worth a Visit, But Manage Expectations
Tip Top Meats presents a bit of a paradox. It boasts a high rating and numerous glowing testimonials praising the staff and range of products. However, the persistent complaints regarding product availability and occasional poor trimming prevent it from achieving a truly flawless reputation.
Potential Customers Should:
- Call Before Visiting: To verify the availability of specific cuts, especially if relying on the website listing.
- Be Prepared for Alternatives: Have backup options in mind in case your first choice is unavailable.
- Appreciate the Service: Be ready to enjoy the welcoming atmosphere and exceptional customer service, which many find redeeming.
- Consider Your Needs: If seeking a specific cut expertly butchered, you may be better served elsewhere. If you prioritize friendly service and a decent selection in a local butcher environment, Tip Top Meats is likely worth a try.
The shop caters to wholesale needs as well as retail, signalling they aim to serve a wide demographic. It’s a local business in Eltham seeking to offer something beyond the standard supermarket experience and, when they succeed, appear to deliver admirably.